
Humans have a long history of battling against the viruses. The constant battle between viruses and scientists has been recognized as a key driver of medical advances. In this series of battles, the latest one is the outbreak of a novel coronavirus, COVID-19, originating in the Wuhan region of China in late December 2019 (Ratan
A vaccine introduces the structure and biological agents of a specific virus to antigen-presenting cells of the host, which engulf it and pass portions of it to activate helper T (Th) cells. The Th cells then trigger other immune responses i.e., activation of B cells and cytotoxic T (Tc) cells. B cells produce antibodies that can prevent the virus from infecting cells, while Tc cells recognize and kill cells that are infected with the virus, that help the surveillance cells of the body to track the virus for long periods (Fig. 2B). In principle, understanding the etiology, epidemiology, pathogenesis and immunobiology of the infection is of the utmost importance for the development of vaccines (Zepp, 2010). Thus, a few simple questions, although complicated to answer, have arisen regarding the basic principles of vaccines that need to be resolved with regard to COVID-19 vaccine development. Here, we aim to address those simple questions.
SARS-CoV-2 is a β-coronavirus belonging to the Sarbecovirus subgenus of the Coronaviridae family, and is enveloped with non-segmented positive-sense RNA virus (Zhu
The Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovations (CEPI), a multilateral and multinational stakeholders foundation for the development of vaccine against infectious diseases, informed in September 2020 that the nine separate technological platforms are being used to make an effective vaccine against SARS-CoV-2 (Gopinathan
Among the ongoing or planned clinical trial as of 11 November 2020, double-blind, single-blind, dose-confirmation, observer-blind randomized, and open-label non-randomized studies are designed for different types of the vaccine from the various technological platform, and of them, there are 18 nucleic acids, 8 Non-replicating viral vectors, 2 replicating viral vector, 9 inactivated virus, 1 virus-like particle, 11 protein subunit, and 3 other candidate vaccines. Moreover, on this clinical trial tally, China is on the top followed by the USA, Australia, Canada, UK, and others (Table 1).
Table 1 . Ongoing or planned clinical trial for COVID-19 vaccine up to 11 November 2020
Candidate | Type | Phase | Study design | Volunteer | Country | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Moderna mRNA-1273 | RNA | 3 | Double-blind randomized | 30000 | USA | NCT04470427 |
WIBP vaccine | Inactivated | 3 | Double-blind randomized | 45,000 | Bahrain, Jordan, Egypt, UAE | NCT04510207 |
Sinovac CoronaVac | Inactivated | 3 | Double-blind randomized | 13,060 | Brazil | NCT04456595 |
Oxford ChAdOx1-S | Non-replicating viral vector | 3 | Double-blind randomized | 40,051 | USA, Chile, Peru | NCT04516746 |
Novavax NVX-CoV2373 | Protein subunit | 3 | Double-blind randomized | 30,000 | USA, Mexico, Puerto Rico | NCT04611802 |
Novavax NVX-CoV2373 | Protein subunit | 3 | Double-blind randomized | 9,000 | UK | NCT04583995 |
Moderna mRNA-1273 | RNA | 3 | Double-blind randomized | 30,000 | USA | NCT04470427 |
Cansino Ad5-nCoV | Non-replicating viral vector | 3 | Double-blind randomized | 40,000 | Pakistan | NCT04526990 |
BIBP/ Sinopharm BBIBP-CorV | Inactivated | 3 | Double-blind randomized | 3,000 | Argentina | NCT04560881 |
Oxford ChAdOx1-S | Non-replicating viral vector | 2/3 | Single-blind randomized | 12,390 | UK | NCT04400838 |
BioNTech BNT162 | RNA | 2/3 | Dose-finding, double-blind randomized | 43,998 | USA, Argentina, Brazil, others | NCT04368728 |
BioNTech BNT162 | RNA | 2/3 | Dose-finding, open-label non-randomized | 43,998 | USA, Argentina, Brazil, others | NCT04380701 |
AZLB protein subunit vaccine | Protein subunit | 2 | Double-blind randomized | 900 | China | NCT04466085 |
Novavax NVX-CoV2373 | Protein subunit | 2 | Single-blind randomized | 4,400 | South Africa | NCT04533399 |
Curevac CVnCoV | RNA | 2 | Dose-confirmation,double-blind, randomized | 691 | Peru | NCT04515147 |
Oxford ChAdOx1-S | Non-replicating viral vector | 1/2 | Double-blind randomized | 2000 | South Africa | NCT04444674 |
WIBP vaccine | Inactivated | 1/2 | Dose-finding, double-blind randomized | 1,264 | China | ChiCTR2000031809 |
Bharat Covaxin | Inactivated | 1/2 | Double-blind randomized | 755 | India | NCT04471519 |
Oxford ChAdOx1-S | Non-replicating viral vector | 1/2 | Single-blind randomized | 1,090 | UK | NCT04324606 |
Zydus Cadila ZyCoV-D | DNA | 1/2 | Double-blind randomized | 1048 | India | CTRI/2020/07/026352 |
CAMS vaccine | Inactivated | 1/2 | Dose-finding, double-blind randomized | 942 | China | NCT04412538 |
Sinovac CoronaVac | Inactivated | 1/2 | Dose-finding, double-blind randomized | 744 | China | NCT04352608 |
Cansino Ad5-nCoV | Non-replicating viral vector | 1/2 | Dose-finding, double-blind randomized | 696 | Canada | NCT04398147 |
CAMS vaccine | Inactivated | 1/2 | Double-blind randomized | 471 | China | NCT04470609 |
Sinovac CoronaVac | Inactivated | 1/2 | Dose-finding, double-blind randomized | 422 | China | NCT04383574 |
Genexine GX-19 | DNA | 1/2 | Dose-finding, double-blind randomized | 210 | Republic of Korea | NCT04445389 |
Aivita AV-COVID-19 | Other | 1/2 | Dose-finding, double-blind randomized | 180 | USA | NCT04386252 |
KBP-COVID-19 | Protein subunit | 1/2 | Observer-blind, dose-finding randomized | 180 | Not Provided | NCT04473690 |
Inovio INO-4800 | DNA | 1/2 | Dose-finding, Open-label (A), double-blind (B) randomized | 160 | Republic of Korea | NCT04447781 |
Arcturus ARCT-021 | RNA | 1/2 | Double-blind randomized | 92 | Singapore | NCT04480957 |
AnGes AG0301-COVID19 | DNA | 1/2 | Dose-finding, Open-label non-randomized | 30 | Japan | NCT04463472 |
Themis V591 | Replicating viral vector | 1/2 | Dose-finding, double-blind randomized | 260 | USA, Austria, Belgium | NCT04498247 |
Inovio INO-4800 | DNA | 1/2 | Dose-finding, open-label (A), double-blind (B) randomized | 160 | Republic of Korea | NCT04447781 |
Novavax NVX-CoV2373 | Protein subunit | 1/2 | Dose-finding, observer-blind randomized | 1,419 | Australia, USA | NCT04368988 |
Imperial LNP-nCoVsaRNA | RNA | 1 | Dose-finding partially randomized | 320 | UK | ISRCTN17072692 |
Medicago CoVLP | Virus-like particle | 1 | Dose-finding, open-label randomized | 180 | Canada | NCT04450004 |
Curevac CVnCoV | RNA | 1 | Dose-finding, single-blind randomized | 284 | Belgium, Germany | NCT04449276 |
PLA-AMS ARCoV | RNA | 1 | Dose-finding randomized | 168 | China | ChiCTR2000034112 |
Moderna mRNA-1273 | RNA | 1 | Dose-finding, open-label non-randomized | 120 | USA | NCT04283461 |
Clover SCB-2019 | Protein subunit | 1 | Dose-finding, double-blind randomized | 150 | Australia | NCT04405908 |
BioNTech BNT162 | RNA | 1 | Double-blind randomized | 144 | China | NCT04523571 |
Inovio INO-4800 | DNA | 1 | Dose-finding, open-label non-randomized | 120 | USA | NCT04336410 |
University of Queensland vaccine | Protein subunit | 1 | Dose-finding, double-blind randomized | 216 | Australia | NCT04495933 |
Symvivo bacTRL-Spike | DNA | 1 | Dose-finding, observer-blind randomized | 12 | Australia | NCT04334980 |
Cansino Ad5-nCoV | Non-replicating viral vector | 1 | Dose-finding, open-label non-randomized | 108 | China | NCT04313127 |
SGMI aAPC | Other | 1 | Open-label non-randomized | 100 | China | NCT04299724 |
SGMI LV-SMENP-DC | Other | 1 | Open-label non-randomized | 100 | China | NCT04276896 |
Themis V591 | Replicating viral vector | 1 | Dose-finding, double-blind randomized | 90 | Belgium, France | NCT04497298 |
Gamaleya Gam-COVID-Vac (Lyo) | Non-replicating viral vector | 1 | Open-label non-randomized | 38 | Russia | NCT04437875 |
AZLB protein subunit vaccine | Protein subunit | 1 | Double-blind randomized | 50 | China | NCT04445194 |
Medigen MVC-COV1901 | Protein subunit | 1 | Dose finding, open-label non-randomized | 45 | Taiwan | NCT04487210 |
Vaxine protein subunit vaccine | Protein subunit | 1 | Double-blind randomized | 40 | Australia | NCT04453852 |
aAPC, artificial antigen presenting cell; AZLB, Anhui Zhifei Longcom Biopharmaceutical; BIBP, Beijing Institute of Biological Products; CAMS, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences; KBP, Kentucky BioProcessing; LV-SMENP-DC, vaccine comprising dendritic cells (DCs) modified with lentivirus (LV) vectors expressing ‘SMENP’ minigene; PLA-AMS, People’s Liberation Army Academy of Military Science; SGMI, Shenzhen Geno-Immune Medical Institute; WIBP, Wuhan Institute of Biological Products.
The challenge for modern vaccinology is to be able to provoke all the requisite steps leading to immune system activation
As mentioned earlier, ACE2 is the route of SARS-CoV-2 infection. However, this receptor plays a vital role in both innate and adaptive immune responses by modulating the antigen present antigen cells that interact with T cells to initiate defense initiatives (Bernstein
Another major concern about immunity against coronaviruses is the endurance of the immune response system. For effective immunization, vaccine-induced long-term regulation of the immune system, especially humoral and cell-mediated arms of the adaptive system, functions through producing the effector cells for the current infection and memory cells for future infections with the pathogenic agent (Clem, 2011). However, a number of studies showed that immune responses against COVID-19 do not last long-term. A study conducted on 285 SARS-CoV-2-infected persons reported that antiviral immunoglobulin-G (IgG) and IgM were increased during the first 3 weeks after symptom onset, and then began to decrease (Long
The genome of coronavirus is highly susceptible to mutations that result in genetic drift and evade immune recognition. Several studies have described this phenomenon. The genetic analysis of 86 complete or near-complete genomes of SARS-CoV-2 disclosed many mutations and deletions in coding and non-coding regions (Phan, 2020). High-resolution mapping of the SARS-CoV-2 transcriptome and epitranscriptome found at least 41 potential RNA modification sites with an AAGAA motif (Kim
In this pressing time, perhaps some drug makers will rush through small-scale human tests that might not provide sufficient scrutiny of side effects or backfires. However, no vaccination is entirely free of any side effects or complications, and most are preventable illnesses (Kimmel, 2002). Recently, the phase 1/2 clinical trial of the ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 (NCT04324606) vaccine against COVID-19 also reported side effects such as fever, pain, muscle aches, chills, headache, and uneasiness. The research team claimed that these effects can be reduced by prophylactic paracetamol (Folegatti
Table 2 . Historical concerns about vaccine safety
Incident | Year | Consequence | Reference |
---|---|---|---|
Cutter Incident | 1955 | Started a polio epidemic. Two production pools accounting for 120,000 doses made by Cutter Laboratories caused 40,000 cases of polio; 51 were paralyzed, and five killed even though the vaccine had passed safety testing. | Offit, 2005 |
Simian Virus 40 (SV40) | 1955 to 1963 | From 1955 to 1963, an estimated 10-30% of polio vaccines administered in the US were contaminated with SV40, leading to the development of a certain type of cancer. | Stratton |
Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV) | 1966 | Of the 20 children who underwent the FI-RSV vaccine trial, 16 needed hospitalization, two died afterwards. On contrary, only one of the 21 control group participants was hospitalized. FDA promptly suspended all clinical trials. | Kim |
H1N1 Swine Flu Vaccine and Guillain-Barré Syndrome (GBS) | 1976 | Increased risk of GBS, a rare neurological disorder. | Schonberger |
Hepatitis B Vaccine (HBV) and Multiple Sclerosis (MS) | 1998 | A relationship between HBV vaccine and MS has been suggested but is disputed. | Ascherio |
Rotavirus Vaccine and Intussusception | 1998 to 1999 | Suspension after 15 cases of intussusception, a bowel obstruction in which one segment of bowel becomes enfolded within another segment. | Iskander |
H1N1 Influenza Vaccine and Narcolepsy | 2009 to 2010 | Concern raised after abrupt-onset childhood narcolepsy was seen in Finland in 2010, but not observed in other countries including in the USA. | Partinen |
Dengue Virus Vaccine- Dengvaxia | 2017 | Excess risk of severe dengue in seronegative vaccine recipients compared to seronegative non-vaccinated individuals. The Philippines stopped their immunization program after getting this warning. | Wilder-Smith, 2020 |
The design and development of an efficacious vaccine is always a complex work, particularly in the case of SARS-CoV-2 that already have been mentioned in the previous sections. On this hurdles race to reach that endpoint of efficacious vaccine, several initiatives can be taken. First, a detailed characterization of COVID-19 immunopathogenesis should be carried out continuously, so that we can have a substantial and scientifically endorsed dataset to make the SARS-CoV-2 more predictable and understandable. Scientists and researchers have already provided several appreciable insights about the novel coronavirus, and they are working relentlessly. As this a global issue and the research is going on a global scale, global collaboration is essential to compare and validate the outcomes of the studies in a wide range of contexts and health care systems. This collaboration and annotating data could break the obstacles and enhance the probability of picking the speed of discovery up as well. Second, utilization of new technologies could overcome those stumble blocks lying in the road of COVID-19 vaccine development. Besides, conventional inactivated or live attenuated virus-vectored, new developments for non-viral vaccines, such as viral particle-like and nanostructures vaccines, subunit vaccines, RNA/DNA vaccines, and the development of rational vaccines, could provide groundbreaking approaches to addressing current vaccine production problems (Brisse
However, there may be no single winner of the vaccine; thus, it will be necessary to standardize different efficiency endpoints to permit reliable estimates and ensuring the deployment of the most successful candidates (Hodgson
The number of morbidities and mortalities related to COVID-19 is increasing day by day. Global and local economies are on the verge of depression, which is exacerbating humanitarian crises across the globe. Most of the countries have imposed lockdown and stay-at-home-strategy to break the chain of the community transmission; however, these preventive methods are not sustainable for a long time. As such, there is a dire need for a vaccine against COVID-19. An efficient vaccine is the best option for controlling and prevention COVID-19 pandemic. Addressing the raised questions in this paper will improve the safety and efficacy of any COVID-19 vaccine.
This research was funded by the Basic Science Research Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF), grant number 2017R1A6A1A03015642.
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
![]() |
![]() |